Buy, Sell, Or Hold American Eagle Stock?
1. AEO reports a 292% increase in first-quarter net income year-over-year. 2. Despite a 40% surge, AEO's stock remains lower than the S&P 500. 3. Earnings per share of $0.45 exceeded consensus by 125%, indicating potential. 4. High debt levels and low margins raise concerns about long-term stability. 5. AEO has historically underperformed during economic downturns, suggesting caution.